From power cords to data connections, copper helps keep modern computing running—a reminder that B.C.’s AI ambitions depend on both responsibly produced minerals and reliable firm power.
From power cords to data connections, copper helps keep modern computing running—a reminder that B.C.’s AI ambitions depend on both responsibly produced minerals and reliable firm power.

Learning from past mistakes

How historical lessons in copper refining can guide B.C.’s approach to AI infrastructure and firm power generation

Canada has been running away from its comparative advantages for decades. The abundance of resources, a vast but sparsely populated landmass, a cold-to-very-cold climate, and world-class talent together make for a prosperous economy of resource extraction, refining, and manufacturing.

By prioritising the service economy, we undermined our sovereignty and economic resilience. Ottawa has now acknowledged this. Now we have to correct the mistakes and avoid making similar ones.

A past example is copper refining, and AI infrastructure may become another.

The copper experience

The percentage of copper refined domestically fell from roughly 67 per cent to 27 per cent between 1990 and 2024.

The decline in copper refining started well before then. In 1948, 95 per cent of copper mined in Canada was refined in Canada. 

By 1987, the capacity was down to five smelters and three refineries in Quebec, Ontario and Manitoba. Today, there is one smelter and one refinery, both in Quebec.

The drivers of the decline were, on the one hand, rising environmental expectations and, on the other, the quest for a higher return on investment. Both goals were met.  

According to Natural Resources Canada (NRCan), we exported $10.7 billion in copper and copper-based products in 2024, largely copper ore concentrate. Meanwhile, we imported $6.5 billion in copper, of which 76 per cent was higher-processed copper products.

NRCan also reported that of the total 514,582 tonnes of concentrate, 348,211 tonnes were exported. Two-thirds of our copper left the country unrefined.

Had the money been invested over the years to keep smelters open, the copper supply chain within Canada would have been wider and longer. Thousands of jobs, both midstream and downstream, would have been created, along with profits and government revenue—a huge lost opportunity that should not be repeated with critical minerals, as laid out in the Canadian Critical Minerals Strategy.

Tech infrastructure is today’s imperative.

Tech infrastructure has become a populist punching bag across the Western world. BC Hydro, at the government’s direction, has taken up the cause more than any other utility in Canada.

The NDP government makes its position clear in the Industrial Electricity Allocation Framework.  

The framework says: 

“Emerging sectors, including AI, data centres, and hydrogen for export, are driving a substantial increase in electricity demand from BC Hydro and create both opportunities and challenges. These industries often require large-scale power at timelines that challenge traditional utility planning while also providing limited socio-economic and/or environmental benefits to British Columbians when compared to electrifying traditional industries such as oil and gas, mining, and liquefied natural gas production.” 

It is unclear whether the government believes that data centres and AI have become vital to the care economy, private and public services, and all industries. Does it recognize that, like copper, data centres touch people’s lives in virtually every way?

Could it be that Traditional public utilities do not plan for an abundance of power? 

Looking forward

B.C. plans to increase the power supply by 20 per cent by 2030 and by 50 per cent by 2050. It is doing so without seriously considering all the tools that could ease the public burden and ensure sufficient firm power. Ontario has taken a different path.

In 1998, Ontario created a significant space for private capital within its energy system. At the time, it was clear that electricity demand would rise just as its nuclear fleet needed refurbishment. 

Ontario appears to be in a better position than British Columbia today because it has private-sector financing for the refurbishment of a large segment of its nuclear fleet and a large share of the 451 MW of battery storage. B.C.’s battery storage program is just getting off the ground. B.C. relies on electricity from rain and snow for more than 90 per cent of its output.

Since 2001, Bruce Power has operated the site under lease, and it is investing $13 billion of private money to refurbish six of its eight reactors. Ontario has now signed a pre-development agreement worth up to $300 million for Bruce C, which would make the site the world’s largest nuclear generating facility.

Trying to meet exploding demand with limited public funds for firm power results in unnecessary rationing. It is prudent to be open-minded rather than dogmatic in critical situations.

Low utility prices are nice, but they mean little if the power isn’t there.

Citizens are looking for alternatives

Today’s consequential shift in electricity demand requires a corresponding change in supply strategy.

British Columbians are not as closed-minded as the current government and support flexibility. An Oct. 1, 2026, Ipsos poll reports that in the province, there is 54 per cent support for allowing nuclear power projects.

To be fair, in the same poll, 69 per cent of residents say they approve of giving data centres a lower priority “to manage electricity demand.” However, in the lead-up to the question, participants were told that “BC Hydro has identified a capacity gap by as early as 2030.” 

It is also fair to ask how people would have answered had they been told B.C. had enough electricity to meet demand.

The First Nations Climate Initiative (FNCI) member Nations are actively exploring the possibility of small modular reactors (SMRs). 

First Nations in B.C. are also showing real interest in AI data centres. Examples include the Upper Nicola First Nation near Merritt, B.C., and the Prophet River First Nation in Northeast B.C..

The B.C. advantage

British Columbia’s greatest advantage is the exceptional energy grid. Ninety-eight percent of BC Hydro’s power is renewable—when we aren’t importing from the US to cover a shortfall. 

Hydroelectricity is becoming less reliable due to droughts, and this trend is expected to continue and worsen. And dams and reservoirs have a very large footprint.

Another advantage is a large landmass with cool to cold temperatures. The trend in large AI centres that train models is for proponents to bring their own power (BYOP), which could fit well along Highway 16 and the CN Rail corridor running from Jasper, Alberta, to Prince Rupert on the Pacific coast. The midpoint between communities along the highway is often about 30 minutes in either direction, with no sprawl to contend with.

The Nordic countries set an example by capitalising on cold temperatures and open spaces.

What’s the point?

Letting the smelting of metals and refining of minerals slip out of Canada, only to buy back the necessary products, was a mistake. Done for environmental reasons and in response to market signals, and for what benefit? The copper is smelted and refined abroad under whatever regulations, and well-paying midstream employment is lost.

British Columbia appears to be on the same path with AI infrastructure; it has capped power for new data centres at 400 MW over two years, compared with nearly 800 MW in applications. 

The tell is: no apparent desire to look at new natural gas generation, no nuclear generation, and no plans to recruit private-sector partners to build firm power. 

B.C. appears comfortable sitting on the sidelines of the Canadian Sovereign AI Compute Strategy, while other provinces with the means are taking advantage of the opportunity. 

This is not a call to shift electricity away from B.C.’s declared priority industries. It is a call for an abundance of electricity.

Jim Rushton is a 46-year veteran of BC’s resource and transportation sectors, with experience in union representation, economic development, and terminal management. Reach him at [email protected].

Resource Works News

Get the latest news with the Resource Works newsletter.

Shaping the Peace: Balancing Energy, Environment, and Equity in Northeast BC's Peace River Region

Help Us Get Things Done

Related News

What are the rules for Net Zero?

Strategic assessment of climate change says new Canadian mines, power plants, pipelines and railways will be covered, but lacks details on how changes to them

A time for reflection

Will BC get a pragmatic 2026 reset on energy and exports?

Natural gas: a way forward for BC and First Nations

Natural gas makes our province an energy giant. But what is LNG, and what does it mean for BC? Josiah Haynes explores.